So yes, the old Randall was just too good - mostly because there was no risk involved.
Now you need at least one other spot in town to spread the word - likely Randall at home, most of the posse in town square, and someone camping out at some deed. Maybe you make it work for you and put Forster Cooke tending bar, or Natalya diverting income.
hopefully flipping Randall p[roves healthier for the game.